Grains Research and Development

Section 1: Herbicide resistance

Section 1.1 - How weed populations become dominated by herbicide resistant plants Section 1.2 - Herbicide resistance in Australia  Section 1.3 - Testing for resistance Section 1.4 - Links to most recent herbicide resistance surveys Section 1.5 - Further information links

glyhosate resistant annual ryegrass
Glyphosate resistant annual ryegrass in wheat
(Photo A. Storrie)

Herbicide resistant weed populations are now found throughout all cropping areas of Australia.At June 2014, there were at least 39 weed species in Australia with resistance to one or more herbicide modes-of-action (MOA). The number of weed species with resistance and the areas affected are increasing (follow this link for up to date details)

A herbicide resistance problem can develop through selection of naturally occurring resistant weeds or already resistant weeds can be imported through flood, animals, or practices such as the purchase of contaminated grain or use of contaminated machinery. Species shift to naturally tolerant species can also occur.

1.1 How weed populations become dominated by herbicide resistant plants.

Naturally occurring resistant individuals exist in the weed population and survive the herbicide application. These survivors produce viable seed which enters the soil seedbank. A proportion of this seed germinates the following season and the resulting plants are also resistant to the particular herbicide(s) used. If the same herbicides continue to be used with no follow up control of survivors, over time the number of resistant individuals increases in the population.

Herbicide resistance fact box
  • Resistance is the inherited ability of an individual plant to survive and reproduce following a herbicide application that would kill a 'wild type' individual of the same species
  • Thirty six weed species in Australia currently have populations that are resistant to at least one herbicide mode-of-action (MOA)
  • As at June 2014, Australian weed populations have developed resistance to 13 distinct MOAs (click here for up to date statistics)
  • Herbicide resistant individuals are present at very low frequencies in weed populations before the herbicide is first applied
  • The frequency of naturally resistant individuals within a population will vary greatly within and between weed species
  • A weed population is defined as resistant when a herbicide at a label rate that once controlled the population is no longer effective (sometimes an arbitrary figure of 20% survival is used for defining resistance in testing)
  • The proportion of herbicide resistant individuals will rise (due to selection pressure) in situations where the same herbicide MOA is applied repeatedly and the survivors are not subsequently controlled
  • Herbicide resistance in weed populations is permanent as long as seed remains viable in the soil. Only weed density can be reduced, not the ratio of resistant-to-susceptible individuals. The exception is when the resistance gene(s) carry a fitness penalty so that resistant plants produce less seed than susceptible ones - but this is rare.

Figure HR1 How a weed population becomes resistant to herbicides

Figure 1. How a weed population becomes resistant to herbicides

Factors influencing the speed of development of herbicide resistance:

  • Initial frequency of resistance gene(s) (and MOA of the applied herbicide) - The higher the frequency the fewer years of herbicide use (selection) are needed to lead to a resistant population.
  • Size of the weed population - The more weeds - the higher the selection pressure.
  • Proportion of the weed population treated - If most of the weed population is sprayed / 'selected' and there are few 'unselected' weed seeds in the soil seed bank when a herbicide is applied, selection for resistance will occur at a much faster rate than if a large number of weed seeds are viable and un-germinated in the soil when the herbicide is applied
  • Herbicide efficacy - The more weeds killed, the higher the selection pressure. The exception is for genes that impart a small / incremental increase in tolerance to the herbicide. Lower doses of herbicide that allow a larger number of weed escapes are more likely to select for a number of 'lower order' resistance genes. Always use robust rates
  • Weed biological factors - Weeds with high population numbers and a high level of genetic diversity are at higher risk
  • Double knock - practices that stop weed survivors from setting seed, or stop that seed entering the seedbank, reduce selection pressure.

1.2 Herbicide resistance in Australia

24D resistant Radish Wongan Hills
2,4-D resistant radish, Wongan Hills
(Photo A. Storrie)

Throughout the world, herbicide resistance is an increasing problem. The International survey of herbicide resistant weeds provides details of worldwide and Australian herbicide-resistant weeds.

In Australia, a large and increasing number of grass and broad-leafed weeds are confirmed as herbicide resistant. Annual ryegrass and wild radish are resistant to the largest number of herbicide modes-of-action and also have the greatest number of resistant populations. A number of weeds such as awnless barnyard grass and windmill grass are resistant to glyphosate and pose a significant threat to Northern no-till farming systems. Resistance to glyphosate in annual ryegrass is now widespread as is wild radish resistant to phenoxies. There has been a rapid increase in weeds resistant to glyphosate since 2007.

The world’s first glyphosate resistance was first discovered at Echuca, Victoria in 1996. As at June 2014, populations from the following species were all confirmed as resistant to glyphosate, with several additional species undergoing process to confirm resistance:

  • annual ryegrass
  • awnless barnyard grass
  • liverseed grass
  • brome grass
  • red brome grass
  • windmill grass
  • flaxleaf fleabane
  • milk/sowthistle
  • wild radish

The first case of paraquat resistance in Australia was northern barley grass in 1983. Paraquat resistance in barley grass is now widespread in lucerne hay and seed crops in south eastern Australia. Small square weed (Mitracarpus hirtus) was the first case of resistance to paraquat in Australia that developed outside of broadacre agriculture.

Three populations of paraquat-resistant annual ryegrass have been confirmed in south eastern South Australia in 2010.

Table 1. Weeds resistant to paraquat in Australia

Species Common name
Arctotheca calendula Capeweed
Hordeum glaucum Northern barley grass
Hordeum leporinum Barley grass
Lolium rigidum Annual ryegrass
Mitracarpus hirtus Small square weed
Vulpia bromoides Silvergrass

All cases of resistance to paraquat are in situations with long histories of use (>15 years).

In 2010 a random survey was conducted in Western Australia and ryegrass seed was collected from 362 of the nearly 470 fields visited (Owen et al in press). Almost 100% of annual ryegrass populations are resistant to Group A ‘fop’ herbicides.  

Table 2. Herbicide resistance in annual ryegrass in Western Australia 2010 (Owen et al in press)

Herbicide % of populations with
resistant plants
diclofop-methyl 96
clethodim (250 mL/ha)
65
clethodim (500 mL/ha)
42
sulfometuron 98
trifluralin 27
Up to date information on weeds confirmed resistant to glyphosate and or paraquat can be found at the Australian Glyphosate Sustainability Working Group Website.

paraquat resistant annual ryegrass
Glyphosate resistant annual ryegrass in a
vineyard in SA
(Photo A. Storrie)
Other sources of up to date information on the herbicide resistance status of Australian weeds can be found at:
http://ahri.uwa.edu.au/research/surveys/

The Australian Glyphosate Sustainability Working Group is a collaborative initiative involving research, industry and extension representatives with the purpose of promoting the sustainable use of glyphosate in Australian agriculture. Their website is a key source of information on glyphosate and paraquat resistance.

CropLife Australia Ltd Herbicide Resistance Management Committee - has developed a series of Resistance Management Strategies for herbicides for most MOA groups. The specific guidelines for the use of crop protection products are designed to reduce the selection pressure for resistance.

Weed species at risk of developing resistance

glyhosate resistant annual ryegrass
Suspected glyphosate resistant
barnyard grass, Bellata, NSW
(Photo T. Cook)

Global examples of herbicide resistance are shown in the table linked here.

In Australian farming systems, the risk of herbicide resistance will be determined by the frequency of herbicide use without seedbank management of survivors and / or the level of competition provided by the crop. Fallow and non-crop areas are often at high risk.

The 20 highest risk weeds for developing glyphosate resistance in the northern grain region are shown in Table 3. The highest risk farming systems were summer fallow and both glyphosate-resistant and non glyphosate-resistant non-irrigated cotton. It is interesting to note that multiple species on the list have already developed glyphosate resistance in this region.

Non-irrigated cotton was generally at a higher risk of developing resistance compared to irrigated cotton due to the historically greater reliance on glyphosate for weed management.

Table 3. Top 20 species in the north eastern grain region at risk of developing glyphosate resistance (Werth et al. 2011)
(R = resistant populations exist, T = populations being tested for resistance)

Species Common name
Brachiaria eruciformis Sweet summer grass (T)
Conyza bonariensis Flaxleaf fleabane (R)
Urochloa panicoides Liverseed grass (R)
Chloris virgata Feathertop Rhodes grass (naturally tolerant)
Sonchus oleraceus Sowthistle/milk thistle (R)
Echinochloa colona Awnless barnyard grass (R)
Eleusine indica Crowsfoot grass
Phalaris paradoxa Paradoxa grass/canary grass
Hordeum spp. Barley grass
Lolium rigidum Annual ryegrass (R)
Dactyloctenium radulans Button grass
Digitaria ciliaris Summer grass
Chloris truncata Windmill grass (R)
Amaranthus hybridus Redshank
Cirsium vulgare Spear thistle
Silybum marianum Variegated thistle
Sorghum halepense Johnsons grass
Eragrostis cilianensis Stink grass
Avena spp. Wild oats/black oats
Lactuca serriola Prickly lettuce (R)

The risk for winter weeds is mainly expansion of current known problems and increasing development of what has been termed 'alphabet resistance', where weeds are resistant to multiple MOA's. Some key threats include:

  • Glyphosate resistance in annual ryegrass, wild oats and a range of other summer and winter grass weeds
  • Group B and I resistance in brassica and other weeds
  • Group A and B resistance in wild oats
  • Extensive use of trifluralin (Group D) over many years in southern Australia has led to widespread and rapidly increasing areas of resistance in annual ryegrass
  • Shepherd's purse (Capsella bursa-pastoris) is also at risk of developing Group B resistance

1.3 Testing for resistance

Testing the herbicide resistance status of weeds provides information on which herbicides still work on the target weeds in that paddock. This essential information on future weed management options potentially saves wasteful use of ineffective herbicides and enables products to be selected to protect crop yield.

Testing can be conducted either by using test strips in the paddock or by sending plants or seeds to a commercial testing service. Paddock tests can provide useful information, but can be difficult to interpret due to variable paddock conditions and the often increased size of weeds when test strips are applied after a spray failure.

Commercial testing services grow and test weeds under glasshouse conditions - thus removing climatic or paddock variability that may affect the results. They are able to easily test a number of different herbicides at several rates and compare the results to standard susceptible and resistant biotypes sprayed at the same time.

Types of test

There are two types of commercial resistance tests:

1. Seed test - seed is collected and sent to the testing service. Results may take up to four to five months. Suitable for pre-emergent and post-emergent herbicides.

2. Quick-test® - live plant seedlings are collected and sent to the testing services. Results within six weeks. Unsuitable for pre-emergent herbicides.

Which paddocks to test

Start with your high risk paddocks

Test any paddock where herbicide resistance is suspected as the cause of a spray failure.

High risk paddocks are those where there is a long history of herbicide use and no conscious management to prevent herbicide survivors from setting seed. These paddocks often have high weed numbers.

The table below gives a rule-of-thumb for the number of years before a problem is likely to develop for the major herbicide groups. These do not need to be consecutive applications.

Table 4. Number of years using a particular herbicide mode-of-action before herbicide resistance is likely to be a problem

Herbicide group Years of application (typical)
B 4
A 'fop' 6
A 'dim' 8
C 10-15
D 10-15
E >15
F 10
G >15
H 10
I >20
K >15
L >15
M >12

When can plants be sampled?

While plants can be sampled before a herbicide is applied (e.g. break of season) their 'skill' in detecting resistance is usually much better when used after herbicides have been applied and poor control is noticed. Sample patches of weeds as this is normally how resistance appears in the early stages. Collecting seed randomly from across the paddock will under-estimate of the level of resistance present as resistant patches could easily be missed.

It is best to sample from patches of weed escapes that become apparent after a herbicide application.

How to sample for testing

Consult the testing service for more details on seed collection for herbicide resistance testing.

Seed test - Approximately 3,000 seeds of each weed (for annual ryegrass an A4-sized envelope full of good seed heads) is required to test multiple herbicides modes-of-action. This equates to about one cup of annual ryegrass seed or six cups of wild radish pods.

Quick-test® - For each herbicide to be tested, 50 plants are required if small with few tillers, or 20 larger later stage tillering plants.

For more information on testing and sampling

Peter Boutsalis, Plant Science Consulting www.plantscienceconsulting.com.au - Quick-test® and seed test

John Broster, Charles Sturt University: Ph: 02 6933 4001 Fx: 02 6933 2924 Email: jbroster@csu.edu.au - seed test only


1.4 Herbicide resistance survey information

 A number of different surveys are available on the extent of herbicide resistance.

Australian glyphosate sustainability working group - their website has a database of confirmed glyphosate resistance cases in Australia

International survey of herbicide resistant weeds - international database, searchable by species, country and mode of action

Australian Herbicide Resistance Initiative (AHRI) - page dedicated to surveys in Western Australian cropping regions

Charles Sturt University, Graham Centre Weed Research Group - CSU conducts screening of weed populations for resistance. Annual reports on results are available on their site.

1.5 Further information

Integrated Weed Management Manual Part 2: Herbicide resistance

GRDC fact sheets and other publications

Groundcover supplement on herbicide resistance

Glyphosate resistance - fact sheet

Herbicide resistance – fact sheet

Taking the test for herbicide resistance - fact sheet

Group A Herbicides in Fallow- fact sheet

Update papers

Managing Clethodim resistant ryegrass (2016)

Herbicide resistance challenges and management strategies southern (2016)

Herbicide resistance challenges and management strategies northern (2016)

Report on the 2014 GOA herbicide resistance survey (2016)

The genetics of glyphosate resistance in barnyard grass, fleabane, windmill grass and feathertop Rhodes grass (2016)

Sowthistle update on glyphosate resistance survey and overview of resistance testing and management options (2016)

Pre-emergent herbicides part of the solution but much still to learn (2015) 

Managing herbicide resistance (2015)

New technology for improved herbicide use efficiency (2015)

Herbicides for control of clethodim-resistant annual ryegrass (2015)

Report on the 2013 GOA herbicide resistance survey (2015)

Quantifying herbicide resistance in modern farming systems – Griffith region 2012/13 (2014)

Pre-emergent herbicides part of the solution but much still to learn (2014)

The mechanisms of herbicide resistance - what are we selecting for and why? (2014)

Herbicides and weeds regional issues trials and developments (2014)

Where is herbicide resistance taking our farming systems (2014)

Weeds and resistance considerations for awnless barnyard grass chloris and fleabane (2014)

Understanding pre emergent cereal herbicides (2014)

Controlling herbicide resistant radish with herbicides in the Northern Agricultural Region (NAR) of WA with a two spray strategy (2014)

Controlling stacked resistance radish with herbicides WA (2014)

Spray resistant radish early for best efficacy and yield WA (2014)

How widespread is resistance (northern) (2013)

Developing a field assay kit to detect glyphosate resistance (northern) (2013)

Strategies for optimising the life of Group A herbicides and patterns of herbicide resistance in wild oats (2011) 

New herbicide management solutions (2011)

Roundup Ready - canola and glyphosate resistance (2009)

Stewardship for Roundup Ready® canola - a focus on the components that reduce potential selection pressure for resistance to glyphosate (2009)

GRDC video links on herbicide resistance

Groundcover TV special on herbicide resistance

Groundcover TV: Herbicide resistance fence-line trials
Trials to evaluate the effectiveness of current and new herbicides for the control of resistant weeds along fence-lines is delivering positive results.

IWM: Resistance Testing - Quick Test Sample Collection
Chris Preston University of Adelaide weeds researcher explains how to collect live weed samples for a herbicide resistance quick test and where to send for testing.

Glyphosate Resistant Summer Grasses - Emergence Patterns & Control
Michael Widderick, DAFFQ Weed Specialist on understanding weed emergence patterns when managing glyphosate resistant summer weeds such as Liverseed, Barnyard and Windmill grass.

Glyphosate Resistant Summer Grasses - Management Strategies
Paul Castor, Consultant MCA Goondiwindi, discusses management strategies for glyphosate resistant summer weeds in broadleaf crops. Double knock timing, pre emergent herbicides and crop choice.

Seed Test - What's involved
Peter Boutsalis, (Plant Science Consulting) explains how to prepare a weed seed sample for resistance testing and how the seed test process works

Other information

WeedSmart

Weed management-it's a numbers game (WeedSmart YouTube clip 2013)

CropLife Australia website has resistance management strategies for fungicides, herbicides and insecticides
Herbicide documents include:

  •   Herbicide mode of action table
  •   Herbicide resistant weeds list
  •   Herbicide resistance management strategies

All are regularly updated on their resistance management page

Australian glyphosate sustainability working group
Information on minimising the risk and impact of glyphosate resistant weeds (http://www.glyphosateresistance.org.au)
Documents on the website include:

Australian Herbicide Resistance Initiative (AHRI)
AHRI conducts scientific and applied research as well as development and extension on many aspects of herbicide resistance and its management in Australian cropping systems. See the links below for more information and further links.

Preserving glyphosate through diversity (AHRI Youtube clip 2012)

WeedSmart in conjunction with AHRI offer a 30 day online course on herbicide resistance called Diversity Era. The course is free, however those interested must register to participate before each live round begins. Visit the Diversity Era website here

Australian Herbicide Resistance Initiative (AHRI) Publications
Working in a number of research areas, AHRI has produced a large number of publications which are available to download. Topics include:

WeedScience.com
An international survey of herbicide resistant weeds

Managing glyphosate resistant weeds in Australia
Christopher Preston pp. 250-253, 17th Australasian Weeds Conference (2010) (CAWS)

Preventing herbicide resistance in 'at risk' weeds (Qld DAF website)

Testing for glyphosate resistance (Qld DAF factsheet)

Risks and RATs: assessing glyphosate resistance risk in paddocks in north-eastern Australia (CAWS paper)

Stopping herbicide resistance in Queensland (Qld DAF factsheet)

Effectiveness of herbicide resistance management strategies  (Qld DAF website)