Local ‘grower practice’ variety trials generate nutrition findings

Author: | Date: 31 Jan 2019

Yardstick trial
Seasonal variation had more impact on the performance of individual wheat varieties than nutrition strategies in trials at Merredin in WA’s eastern grainbelt. Photo: MADFIG

Trials at Merredin in Western Australia’s eastern grainbelt have demonstrated that fertiliser decisions largely do not affect the relative local performance of different wheat and barley varieties in this low rainfall environment.

Yield and grain quality rankings for wheat and barley varieties grown using local management practices – especially for crop nutrition – were shown to be reasonably consistent with those achieved in adjacent Grains Research and Development Corporation (GRDC) National Variety Trials (NVT).

The Merredin and Districts Farm Improvement Group (MADFIG) administered the ‘Yardstick’ trials over three years from 2015, with investment from the GRDC and support from the Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD). The trials were established and managed by service providers Kalyx and Living Farm.

This project, identified as a priority by grower group MADFIG and the Kwinana East GRDC Regional Cropping Solutions Network (RCSN) group, was designed to add value to NVT testing by using typical local grower nutrient management practices adjacent the NVT site.

The GRDC NVT program provides access to independent results on the performance of recently released grain and field crop varieties. It is a national program of comparative crop variety testing with standardised trial management, data generation, collection and dissemination.

Merredin grower and MADFIG member Andrew Crook said the Yardstick trials were initiated after a series of dry seasons highlighted the importance of getting variety choice right and raised questions about whether varieties differed in their responses to fertiliser management.

“During this period, some local growers questioned whether NVT results were fully applicable to them given the standard amount of fertiliser used in the NVT trials was higher than rates commonly used by growers in the area,” Mr Crook said.

“However, results from three years of the Yardstick trials have shown that variety performance rankings, especially for wheat, are reasonably consistent with NVT variety rankings in the area.

“This should give local growers confidence that varieties that perform well within the NVT program should also perform well when grown under their own management systems.”

Yardstick trials 2
The GRDC has invested in several ‘Yardstick’ trials in WA, which are being locally managed and run in each of the State’s grain-receival port zones. Photo: MADFIG

Mr Crook said the trials also highlighted that seasonal variation had a greater impact on individual variety performance than nutrition strategies.

“This highlights the importance of understanding the key factors that will influence variety performance and how they will perform across seasons,” he said.

The trials, on medium-to-heavy textured soils, evaluated 10 wheat varieties and five barley varieties in 2015, 12 wheat varieties and five barley varieties in 2016, and 14 wheat varieties and six barley varieties in 2017.

Four nutrition strategies were implemented across the wheat and barley trials to represent various district fertiliser strategies reflective of common seasonal or budgetary scenarios.

Three of the treatments remained the same for the three seasons and a ‘play the season’ strategy differed depending on rainfall.

Fertiliser strategies included lower rates of phosphorus and generally lower rates of nitrogen than those used in the adjacent NVT trials.

“The results indicate that some fertiliser is equal to, or better than none, for all varieties tested across the seasons,” Mr Crook said.

“Recognising favourable seasons and responding with appropriate management is the challenge, as there is a greater opportunity cost from not maximising profit potential in a favourable season.

“Equally, the trial results show the importance of being conservative in a dry season.”

Mr Crook said MADFIG acknowledged the vital role of Merredin-based DPIRD staff Vanessa Stewart and Jenni Clausen in the delivery of the trials and research outcomes. The support from Ms Clausen was possible due to her involvement in the DPIRD and GRDC project ‘Building crop protection and production agronomy research and development capacity in regional WA’.

In 2018, the GRDC invested in several other similar Yardstick trials, which are being locally managed and run in each of WA’s five grain-receival port zones.

The GRDC has recently produced a video and podcast about its national NVT program. To view the video, go to http://bit.ly/2zSO5My. To listen to the new GRDC podcast, go to http://bit.ly/2CT2FoC.

Contact Details

For Interviews

Andrew Crook, MADFIG
0429 412 141


Natalie Lee, GRDC
09 9230 4600, 0427 189 827

GRDC Project code: MDF00001, DAW00256